Netbook comparator

netbooks

Our recent netbook post got a huge response. They are almost unanimously loved. A few dissenting opinions were present though. A few people mentioned that until this generation arrived, they were buying used subnotebooks for exactly the same reasons.

If you’re in the market for a new machine, Obsessable’s netbook comparator has all of the current models broken down by feature.

Comments

  1. J says:

    LOL at the macbook Pro comment. I’ve got one open here and it’s HARDLY faster than my eee 1000h- in both specs AND actual use.

  2. J says:

    And the eee has a bigger hard drive! Remember kids, using a standard one is OK as long as you’re prepped to replace it if it fails!

    Also, virtual disks are faster, with cheap flash drives now are easier to move around, keep and store too- also, re-installing if MUCH faster off a pen drive.

    Life is better without disk drives for me. I haven’t used the dual 16X dvd copy setup in months because i’d rather keep everything as ISO’s… and don’t even get me started on Bluray. Give me a corsair flash drive any day.

    Here’s to hoping flash media continues to improve until everyone can operate the way I do. It’s quite convenient.

  3. pski says:

    @j: Flash drives ftw!

  4. alex says:
  5. BigD145 says:

    I still refuse to use the word n3tb00k. They are, and always will be, laptops. Aside from the cost issue, they are the original old definition of a laptop.

  6. I like the idea of a netbook which would be better on the go then my notebook and speed is not a issue since would only be used for browsing the internet. They do need to hit the $200 price mark to justify when already have a notebook.

    Hacking the Machine – Trying to take back control in our increasingly technology driven world

  7. jjrh says:

    I still can’t believe laptops these days come with non (easily)removable cd-roms. Who really uses optical drives a day to day basis? The space is much better used on my laptop(thinkpad) to hold another battery or hdd. Even if you couldn’t use the drivebay for other things besides the CDROM, just having the less weight and less power usage is a real benefit.

    If I was buying my system again now, I would probably go for a netbook and a desktop, opposed to a nice laptop.

  8. floreign says:

    Since the idea of ultraportables (extremely rarely below $1000) is not new, the only new idea related to the netbooks is them being cheap (but still more expensive than they’re worth) and the sluggish processor.

    Since legitimate cinema issues are only on DVD or Blu-Ray, and definitely not on flash drives, I will not use them at all, not even as a temporary method, until either ultraportables become cheap, or netbooks solve their processor/chip problems that are severely limiting their performances.

  9. _matt says:

    The problem I have with netbooks are the ones that come with 3-cell batteries.

    and that site isn’t completely accurate.
    my eee pc 1000 has a 160gb hard drive, wireless n, and xp home.

    if a netbook can only last 3 hours, why get it when i can get a system with a core 2 duo with the same battery life?

    one thing i’d like to point out about those who bash netbooks because of their computing power, i know plenty of people who are happy surfing internets on their phone.

  10. TripleOG says:

    anyone remember the philips velo 1? the grandpappy of netbooks. tiny ass greyscale screen, like 4.5in or something. built in 14kbs modem, as wireless was unheard of in ’98’. ran WIN CE on a 30something MHz proc. like 8MB storage but served it purpose well. (mobile data input,email,business contacts,greyscale porn) and the killer? around 20hr battery life. and a touchscreen… in 1998 it was no problem, why the hell now? it was cheap too, like $250.

  11. Aaron Andrusko says:

    I wanted to add a few thoughts. After my posting in the netbook bashing comments, A friend sold me an acer one for $200.
    It’s a lot better than the eees I had used. Gone was the cheap plastic and in its place was less cheap plastic. A real 2.5″ sata drive that I could upgrade to 7200rpm isn’t too bad also.
    Am I coming over to the other side? Not quite.

    Years back I got one of the first released sony vaio U3s in Japan. It was not bad at the time. Transmeta crusoe, 6″ xga lcd, 1gb ram, 1.8″ pata hdd and usb 1.1. its about two thirds the size of this acer one. It cost about $1400.

    Things are getting better, but they are not even close to perfect yet.

    If HP could get the aesthetic/build quality of the mini note, with the atom + discrete gpu combo on some next gen chipset for $500, that would be nice.

    I don’t know if the market would bear it though.

    I’d never pay $400 for this machine but I will admit it has a place. It should be fun to see what comes next year.

  12. Coderer says:

    I’m not jumping on the “bashwagon”, but I do think that any device with a screen lower than 1024×768 is only useful with a custom, purpose-built browser that takes the tiny real estate into account. I can use a browser on my WM phone, or the iPhone version of Safari, or one of the several browsers for Nokia’s “internet tablets”, but each of them has to redesign user interaction from the ground up to be worth a damn. My problem with many of the smaller/lower-end netbooks is that they tend to drop under the critical pixel count but stick you with desktop-type browsers (at least out of the box).

  13. Aaron Andrusko says:

    I very much agree on the resolution issue. At least the contrast ratio is good on the led display, otherwise it would be a write off.

    The F11 key is your friend for sure.

  14. yuppicide says:

    Great post. I found the MSI Wind for $299. Might pick one up for my Girlfriend’s Daughter. We just need something cheap for her so she can stop using our computer for teenage crap (you know MySpace, etc).

  15. mike says:

    Make sure before you get one of these you check out the CPU benchmarks… you might be [unpleasantly] surprised.

  16. geo says:

    I have had small computers for many years, including a 9″ Everex i486 DX laptop, a Compaq WinCE “palm top” with a 5″ mono display, and one of the earliest “real computers” of miniscule proportion, the Atari Portfolio, which had an 80C88 cpu, at 4.9mhz, 128k of ram and apps in a 256k rom. It also had a non-backlit mono display, and a text-only interface, using a special modified DOS. It also used standard AA batteries, which could power it for over 2 weeks! There was no “internet” in those days, but it could connect to a BBS (google it!) with its primitive modem which, if I recall correctly, used sounds from the speaker to dial and connect using a regular telephone handset. (I tried, but was never able to get it to connect over my old Motorola “brick phone”.) It was pretty cool in its day, but alas, I lost mine when I put it on top of my car and drove off, and never saw it again….

    I just bought an MSI Wind U100 to replace my Acer Aspire One that was stolen after I had it only 3 months. Both are great machines, serve their purpose well, and are inexpensive, even compared to the “original netbook” eeePC. Sadly, the concept of the netbook has been co-opted to being just a inexpensive mini-laptop, and not really true to the original concept. The original concept was, (at least as it appeared to me to be) a SMALL, CHEAP, DURABLE device that cold be used to surf the internet, create and edit office docs, and maybe play some media files. There are some new ones coming soon, such as the HiVision $98 netbook, which very much resembles the original eeePC. While I am enjoying my new MSI Wind, I will probably get one of these also.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 96,544 other followers