How Do Squid React To Being Shocked To The Beat Of Cypris Hill?

Well, they probably get annoyed.

Cephalopods have a nifty trick where they can change color by altering the size and shape of chromataphors, or “colored cell thingy blobs”. Like most cells, these chromataphors react to electricity in different ways. Mainly, expanding and contracting.

The folks at Backyard Brains, a group that does neuroscience at home, have decided to run an experiment where they pump the signal from Cypris Hill’s song Insane in the membrane right into the nerve on a fin of a squid to see how the chromatophrs react. Not surprisingly, they pulse to the beat.

Just because it isn’t a surprise, doesn’t mean its not fun to watch.

55 thoughts on “How Do Squid React To Being Shocked To The Beat Of Cypris Hill?

    1. This is unbelievably cruel! There’s absolutely no excuse for this kind of behavior. How would you like it if someone used your music in and awesome video and then spelled your name wrong?

    2. OK, I’ll bite.

      Without being too po-faced about it (I’m not any kind of animal rights campaigner), it does seem a bit ethically challenged. A bit like kids pulling the legs off spiders.

      The point that most “animal liberationists” are trying to make is not about preventing all animal suffering, but to prevent unnecessary suffering, particularly for things like entertainment.

      You won’t find Backyard Brains throwing each other into a bathtub with an electric eel in it, for instance, although I’ll bet that would be just as entertaining and informative. It would also be ethically sound as they would presumably have a choice in the matter.

      I’m guessing that empathy is not their long suit.

      1. In addition to actually reading the comments, and maybe even the attachments, you could have done some very basic electrical calculations and realized that at the voltage and current levels applied, even a live squid would feel nothing – Just like you don’t feel an electrical shock every time one of your muscles is used.

        If you don’t believe me, cut your ear buds off, expose the wires to your hand and play the song in question. Even if you wet your skin first, you will feel nothing.

    1. first, half of you see the cool insperational side of nature. the other half seem to not understand that animal research is not full of people intentually harming animals for $**ts and gigs, i have had a similar procedure done to my leg. it is simple and painless. elctrodes are attached to the skin and very small voltages are applied.

      2nd a 100 watt amp would probably not reach a high enough potential to penitrate human skin, but if it did would kill the victum out right, and fry all of their nerves. science isn’t distroying things for fun, and you shouldnt either.

      1. Uhmm, having actually felt the output of a 400 Watt (RMS) amp designed for pushing into 2ohms, I can categorically state that it hurts ‘quite a lot’. You would not want this on your testicles.

        Having received many other shocks in my time, I’d rate it at worse than Christmas lights & camera flashes.

      1. First, the squid was already dead. They didn’t hurt it at all.

        Second, comparing the ~0.3v/5mA from a headphone output to the 100v/10A signal of a 1000W amp is ludicrous. They’re not even the same thing. That’s like the difference between licking a 9V battery and touching the hot wire on 120v/60Hz AC.

        Third, neurological cells are mostly consistent in size between animals, meaning the squid’s nerves are made of about the same size cells yours are. This means that there would be very little difference in the capacity to withstand power, at least when applied directly to the nerves as was the case in this experiment.

  1. What is wrong with you people?!

    The OPs article is straightforward animal torture plain and simple. I simply cannot believe that so many people find causing *needless suffering* to animals so enjoyable!

    As presented, there seems to be *no* redeeming scientific point to or educational basis for this work. This dubious “experiment” is ethically equivalent to Mengele injecting dye into people’s eyes at Auschwitz “just to see what happens”. It is 100% Nazi death science.

    Tell me, if the animal featured in the OPs original experiment was a cute kitten or puppy instead of a squid would you all find this quite so amusing? Some people here need to question themselves I think!

    Moreover I am disappointed that Hackaday have sought to draw attention to – and presumably indirectly profit from, via advertising revenue – something quite so ethically unsound. As budding amateur scientists, this is definitely *NOT* the sought of behaviour that we should be promoting, encouraging or even drawing attention to!

    1. Did you even RFTA? Have you missed the fact that, as mentioned in the article, and as numerous people have pointed out, the squid was already dead?

      Please save the preaching until after you’ve gotten all the facts.

  2. This seems to be an horrible way to obtain a useless audio spectrum analyzer. Next time, instead of playing with animals giving them pain for no reason, you can simply install Winamp and MilkDrop plug-in: better results without having animals suffering. Cypress Hill, not Cypris Hill.

  3. Animal activists are like a yard full of Chihuahuas. They sound the alarm at every cricket chirp and squirrel fart until everyone is tired of listening to them. When an actual real issue does come around nobody will listen.

    Cool Hack.

    1. The real issue here is about whether this is some nasty, sadistic, adolescent creeps doing unnecessary “research” which is contributing nothing to the fund of human knowledge, or simply some sort of vile-but-cool screensaver. What is cool about this? This sort of effect was being taught when I was at school (circa 50 years ago) but was demonstrated using frogs legs which we had to cut off ourselves. Yeah, electricity stimulates neurons. We’ve known that for well over a century. Google it or get over it.

      By all means love tech, but don’t lose your humanity in the process. When you’ve grown up a bit you may well find that this stuff starts to revolt you and that people who do it for fun start to creep you out because you’ve started to understand what else comes with that psychological package.

      Think of the kids, that *every* school has, who get off on shit like dissecting live insects and seeing what happens when you prod a scalpel into their brains. Are any of them not just sad, alienated, wankers? Yuk Yuk Yuk…

      1. I had a similar initial impression. Electricity stimulates neurons, so the result is predictable. Therefore, the experiment is unnecessary, and possibly cruel.

        Then I watched the video, which was unexpectedly fascinating. It was not just entertaining, but also scientifically interesting; as the individual chromatophores responded in more complex ways than I predicted. Therefore, it does have some value.

        The ethics are still debatable. I don’t presume to have the right answer, that’s why I’ve so far stayed out of that aspect of the discussion.

        But your comment makes me want to point out something. Even if you fully know about a scientific principle from dry text, curiosity and wonder at seeing it demonstrated – and especially demonstrating it for yourself – is also a part of being human. For your sake, I hope it isn’t as faded with your advanced years as your comment seems to indicate.

        1. That last paragraph is important. Science isn’t some collection of facts previously determined and published somewhere. Science is the process of figuring out how the world (or components therein) work.

  4. I am not saying this is EVIL and should be stopped RIGHT NOW.

    I am saying that’s it’s not very fun, and that those of you who feel nothing is wrong here at all, well maybe you guys don’t have as much of the natural impulse for empathy.

  5. For those of you justifying it by the miniscule amount of voltage, just remember, this animal is less than 1 pound in size.. What is your weight? Now lets pump up the equivalent voltage for your weight and hook you up.. think you’ll feel it then???

    -1.. Dislike… I recommend removing this post..

    1. Voltage response doesn’t scale with body size like you suggest. The nerves in a squid operate on the same principles as our nerves, meaning they react to voltages in the same way.

  6. Just searched for and found the note saying that it was dead.. (small comment at the bottom of the page) I really had to dig for it. But it doesn’t change anything.. Lets do what I wrote above to the guy after he’s dead. What that’s disrespectful? you don’t wanna make him into a dancing zombie?

    HAD.. I’m sorry but you lost one respect point for this post..

    1. “Lets do what I wrote above to the guy after he’s dead. What that’s disrespectful? you don’t wanna make him into a dancing zombie?”

      We are talking about a squid here.

      Nonetheless, if it will help students to understand the body and biology better, then I for one fully consent to using my body in this manner after I’m dead. What use is this body to me at that point, and why should I be concerned about respect?

    2. So you would suggest that we stop eating them as well, since it would be disrespectful to eat dead people? Dare I mention that the squid’s cousin the octopus is routinely eaten alive, and that our most dearest crustation the lobster is BOILED ALIVE before being eaten.

      Base point, if it can be bought at the grocer for eating it is not unethical to zap it with electricity, however it may be ill mannered to play with your food.

    3. oh so now it isn’t good enough that the creature was dead?! You’re complaining that it’s being turned into a zombie?? This article should’ve been called ‘how do idiots react to a dead squid being slightly shocked to the beat of Cypress Hill!

  7. From the same people who eat chicken or beef everyday (and sometimes fried calamari)…

    Okay, yes we know electricity is what make nerves tick, great!
    Okay, this does nothing to advance science, granted!
    But the point here is education. The repetition of past experiments helps the learner to understand how we got to the current state of knowledge in the first place. It’s fun, it’s interesting, it’s intense and that’s what makes so much more memorable than reading about it in a book.

    So stop complaining, or refrain from eating meat altogether.

Leave a Reply

Please be kind and respectful to help make the comments section excellent. (Comment Policy)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.