Think You Need A New PC For Windows 11? Think Again

As the sun sets on Windows 10 support, many venues online decry the tsunami of e-waste Windows 11’s nonsensical hardware requirements are expected to create. Still more will offer advice: which Linux distribution is best for your aging PC? [Sean] from Action Retro has an alternate solution: get a 20 year old Sun Workstation, and run Windows 11 on that. 

The Workstation in question from 2005 is apparently among the first Sun made using AMD’s shiny new 64-bit Opteron processor. Since Windows has no legacy 32-bit support– something it shares with certain Linux distributions– this is amongst the oldest hardware that could conceivably install and run Redmond’s latest.

And it can! Not in unaltered form, of course– the real hack here is courtesy of [ntdevlabs], whose “Tiny11” project strips all the cruft from Windows 11, including its hardware compatibility checker. [ntdevlabs] has produced a Tiny11Builder script that is available on GitHub, but the specific version [Sean] used is available on Archive.org.

[Sean] needed the archived version of Tiny11 because Windows 11 builds newer than 22H2 use the POPCNT operation, which was not present in AMD’s first revision of the x86_64 instruction set. POPCNT is part of Intel’s SSE4 extension from 2007, a couple years after this workstation shipped.

If you’re sick of being told to switch to Linux, but can’t stomach staying with Windows either, maybe check out Haiku, which we reported as ready for daily driving early last year.

 

25 thoughts on “Think You Need A New PC For Windows 11? Think Again

    1. As a Win10 user that’s not planning to go Win11, what’s the difference between Win10 LTSC and the “regular” one? Would I need to reinstall the whole system to switch?

      1. It’s windows with a lot of stuff stripped out by default, so no windows store, cortana, and other things, it also only gets security updates not feature updates, so it stays more static. This is why LTSC is meant for environments where stability is more important than features. I’ve used it for several years now with no issues, so you aren’t missing out on much.
        Microsoft don’t advertise it, but you can just download Win 10 LTSC and Win 11 IoT LTSC ISOs directly from them, so you don’t need to look in sketchy places for it, fire them up in a VM and have a go. You can even look into tiny10 or tiny11 if you really want to try barebones stripped out versions, but I’ve not personally done it.

    2. ten ltsc is awesome, but haven’t evaluated 11 ltsc yet. it might be the stopgap if i dont find a linux distro i like. but i got till 10 ltsc reaches the end of its service life.

  1. Great article showing Win11 on some unusual vintage hardware. Using Tiny11 is kind of a work around but it is too stripped down to be useful or safe for a regular user. I have told friends that over bought into the M$ hype that their computers will not shutdown. They will however get some peace from the updates that bork things. If they want 11…RUFUS or Flyoobe… problem fixed

    1. RUFUS, for anyone who isn’t familiar, is a tool for creating bootable disks & installation media on USB sticks. It has some options for creating Windows 11 media that allow you to install it on PCs that don’t meet some of the minimum requirements, like TPM 2.

      I recently did a fresh install of Windows 11 on an older HP Elitebook 840 G3 (6th gen i5, no TPM 2). RUFUS made bypassing the TPM 2 requirement easier than I’d thought.

      1) Download the Windows 11 ISO here: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows11
      2) Use the Rufus bootable USB tool to create a USB installer. Rufus will present you with options to remove TPM 2 and other checks: https://rufus.ie/en/

      So far, so good

      1. Thank you. I didn’t elaborate because I thought both utilities were common knowledge in the PC world. These utilities allow you to set up an install pen drive for either 10 or 11. I have used RUFUS for the past year to set up over 25 pc’s with no problems and they all receive updates. One main reason to use this if your computer doesn’t meet the high hardware specifications, mainly TPM (Trusted Platform Module). This is used for Bitlocker which encrypts your hard drive for security. Bitlocker has been shown to slow down a computer. Some of the other advantages to the utilities is the ability to disable or reduce M$ telemetry-spying and the setup of a local account instead a M$ login account ( it’s your PC, why do you need to let them know you’re using it ). There is also a list of Powershell scripts that remove bloatware that run in background because removing the app doesn’t do the job. Instead of pitching a good working computer… recycle/repurpose/reuse/extend its life….kind of the mantra here.

  2. Still more will offer advice: which Linux distribution is best for your aging PC? [Sean] from Action Retro has an alternate solution: get a 20 year old Sun Workstation, and run Windows 11 on that.

    That’s . . . that’s not a solution to what to do with my old hardware;)

  3. 22H2 “doesn’t count” if you are looking for a version that will keep getting security updates. But it’s good to see the tips and tricks in the comments section to bypass the hardware-checks so if you have POPCNT-compatible hardware you can do the up-to-date version of Windows 11.

    [Sean] from Action Retro: If you find a way to virtualize POPCNT so you can get the current version of Windows 11 or its successor running on that ancient hardware, please do another HaD post.

  4. Is it possible to run Win11 withOUT OneDrive? System ran fine, I was just tired of seeing it. Deleted the OneDrive folder and rhe whole system runs terribly slow now. And files were lost. Again. Despite never consenting to having confidential client files automatically moved to the cloud, for ease of hacking by malicious actors.

  5. Is there any way to remove their OneDrive garbage? I deleted the folder, lost some confidential files (again) and the sytem just seems to run a lot slower now too.

Leave a Reply to scott_txCancel reply

Please be kind and respectful to help make the comments section excellent. (Comment Policy)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.