When you’re sick or have a headache, you tend to see things a bit differently. An ill-feeling human will display a cognitive bias and expect the world to punish them further. The same is true of honey bees. They are intelligent creatures that exhibit a variety of life skills, such as decision-making and learning.
It was proven back in 2011 that honey bees will make more pessimistic decisions after being shaken in a way that simulates an attack by varroa destructor mites. The bees were trained to associate a reward of sugar-water with a particular odor and to associate foul-tasting punishment water with another odor—that of formic acid, a common treatment against varroa mites. When a third stimulus created by mixing the two odors was presented, the experimenters found that the aggravated bees were more likely to expect the bad odor. Sure enough, they kept their tongues in their mouths when they smelled the third odor. All the bees that weren’t shaken looked forward to sucking down a bit of sugar-water.
So, how does one judge a honey bee’s response? Whenever their antennae come in contact with something appetizing, they stick out their proboscis involuntarily to have a taste. This is called proboscis extension reflex (PER), and it’s the ingrained, day-one behavior that leads them to suck the nectar out of flower blossoms and regurgitate it to make honey.
[LJohann] is a behavioral biologist who wanted to test the effects of varroa mite treatment on bee-havior by itself, without agitating the bees. He built a testing apparatus to pump odors toward bees and judge their response which is shown in a few brief demo videos after the break. This device enables [LJohann] to restrain a bee, tantalize its antennae with sucrose, and pump a stimulus odor at its face on the cue of an LED and piezo buzzer. A fan mounted behind the bee helps clear the air of the previous scents. We especially like the use of a servo to swing the tube in and out of the bee’s face between tests.
[LJohann] and his colleagues concluded that the varroa mite treatment by itself does not make the bees pessimistic. This is great news for concerned apiarists who might be skeptical about using formic acid in the fight against the honey bee’s worst predator. Check out the brief demo videos after the break.
Hackaday has long been abuzz about bees whether they produce honey or not. We’ve covered many kinds of sweet projects like intelligent hives, remote hive weight monitoring, and man-made bee nest alternatives.
10 thoughts on “Hassle-Free Classical Conditioning For Honey Bees”
So I’m thinking, why don’t you breed a bee with a dribbly stinger so it keeps grooming formic acid over itself ???
Or force them to go through a hive entrance that has walls moistened with Formic acid that they are forced to rub up against.
Someone already followed that line of thought:
Anyhow, with varoa we are dealing with a biological evolutionary pressure, and it should soon result in an overturn of the tide. Already there exist bees which perform VSH and keep the infestation under control themselves. The bees won’t perish just like that.
Or I’d be thinking, do salts of formic acid work? That bees might not find so obnoxious.
Part of the draw of formic acid is it’s volatile & doesn’t absorb into the honey / wax. It vaporizes and fumigates the colony. A problem with formic salts is they are going to be weaker acids than formic acid is already, so they probably won’t be strong enough to kill of the mites (many other acids aren’t eg; vinegar). Additionally it’s going to have a different evaporation point so you may not be able to apply it when the hive is most at risk (cool weather).
It might be easier to counter condition your hives to like the smell of formic acid.
Pessimistic bees! Great. Next maybe we can make some with crippling social anxiety.
Maybe they exist already … https://www.growwilduk.com/content/everything-you-need-know-about-solitary-bees
Wait, bee barf is honey? Next you’ll tell me that Soylent Green is people. On a sorry note I lost two hives some years ago. I’m glad to see research into what ails them.
Amazing research! And a hack!
This could be useful for other things as well. Some people were looking into something similar for bomb-sniffing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DMGbf6pGOUg
Please be kind and respectful to help make the comments section excellent. (Comment Policy)