Election night holographic interviews

obama_holo

Instead of the normal head in a window or split screen display used when interviewing remote guests, [Wolf Blitzer] will be interviewing 3d holograms. Supposedly, they will be recording in a way that allows for 360 views to be projected on stage with [Wolf]. We’ll have to wait and see exactly how they plan to pull that off, but our suspicion is that it will be similar to the Gorillaz live performances. Join us after the break to watch one.

Comments

  1. pip says:

    This does it. I’m leaving you.

  2. theisovist says:

    Whoa! I’m glad i clicked on this comments, I got to see pip finally leave! Cheerio good chap!

  3. I’m guessing it will be an entirely post-camera, digital effect–like standard green-screen “superimposing”, but with provisions for dynamic camera angle changing. Something akin to those glyph tracking demos, but with a live human’s image in place of the 3D models. I mean, what would be the point in doing even a simple live pseudo-hologram effect when 99.9% of the people seeing it will be doing so via the decidedly 2D media of television?

  4. Jim K. says:

    Just saw it in operation and wow I’m completely underwhelmed. Like a really bad green screen circa 1982.

  5. It also seems almost offensive that they are pretending that they can actually see the “hologram” in the room. It’s so obviously a video overlay, i wish they would just be honest and not try to pretend. Wolf Blitzer sits there saying “wow i can see you right there in front of me, in 3d!” like some bad TV actor trying to explain the plot through supposedly realistic dialogue – like saying “Oh no, we are very far from home and all we have to communicate is this one cell phone. I hope we don’t lose it, then we’d be in biiiig trouble!”

    If they had just not said anything about it, and let the effect just be an effect, it wouldn’t be too bad, but listening to him try to sell it when its obviously not real is just lame.
    -Taylor

  6. What do I win for calling it?

  7. Caleb Kraft says:

    @jake of all trades
    you get a cookie, good call.

    Yeah, this looks just like compositing with matched camera angles. Very similar to what we do in the 3d animation industry.

  8. Xeracy says:

    Seriously though, when I saw this on TV, (after all the ‘help me wolf blitzer, you’re my only hope’ jokes) Its really just 3 cameras that capture him from the front, back and a side. This is what I equate to Wolfenstein 3D’s Ray-Casting…

  9. Iv says:

    Gorillaz used a semi-transparent glass at a 45° angle between the public and the scene. The projection is made from the bottom. It is not holographic. You only get only one POV

  10. strider_mt2k says:

    The Emperor will now sit still for this.

  11. fartface says:

    What they did was a very poor Green screen effect.

    what Gorrillaz did is based on real tech…

    http://www.eyeliner3d.com/

    and having seen it in person it’s not as good as you think it is, but way more impressive than the really lame CNN trick from the 70’s.

  12. klecu says:

    I wonder if they made it look worse just so people would think it was a real hologram.

  13. Gosh says:

    there is a great disturbance in the force! someone has stolen our technology! send in the tie fighters!

  14. gian says:

    Of course there was greenscreen involved. How do you think they separated the ones being interviewed from their background? This does not mean it’s fake!!!

  15. Bill says:

    My favorite part was how Wolf described her being inside some complicated tent that took three weeks to assemble. They must have the same tent I have…. man that thing is impossible to set up. I rarely even bother attaching the hadron collider, not to mention the holograph module.

    Cheesiest effect ever, for sure. They should have actually had ILM come in and do it right instead of just making the star wars jokes and looking stupid.

  16. RWL says:

    @gian: no, the fact that the image did *not* appear in the studio with blitzer means that it’s fake. it was just video effects, nothing more. not even cutting-edge effects, either.

    so that blitzer would know what they were doing, the guests’ images were displayed on a monitor in the studio. and there was a bright painted circle on the stage, so he’d know where to face so it appeared he was looking at a real image.

    I call *fake* on cnn!

  17. neelster says:

    Worst stunt ever. It’s not THAT technologically advanced they just the resolution of the digital image (on tv…obviously there’s nothing in the studio) is horrible.

  18. JohnJ says:

    They described 30+ high def cameras in the tent, but the quality was seriously low as we saw.

    If anyone caught the (one time?) demonstration of the house of representatives on the holographic table an hour before the Princess Leia demo, it reminded me of ARToolkit and a video overlay with tracking.

    Then I spotted that ARToolkit already has something along the Leia lines called 3D-Live, which runs at QVGA (PAL) res of 352×288 using 15 cameras. Demo videos online already look better than what CNN came up with.

    I suppose the problem was that they were feeding all of the video input from offsite back to HQ to render the angles, which is a terrible waste of bandwidth IMHO.

    It likely would have worked much batter if they shot from waist up and placed the virtual actor behind a desk with a single angle. Obviously, still utilizing the imagination of the actor sitting next to them, but they could be looking at an off-set screen like weather folks usually do.

  19. Dracc says:

    Unfortunately the video linked to in the article is a much more elegant and REAL technology. The Gorillaz concerts were created using the Musion Eyeliner technology, a variation on Pepper’s ghost. The images are still 2D, but are projected onto a meshed projection screen that is nearly invisble under dark lighting conditions, so that they appear to exist 3Dimensionally suspended in space. The Gorillaz are actually visible to the live audience. CNN’s crap is no more complicated than drawing lines on a football field in realtime. For slightly more information check out http://www.eyeliner3d.com/musion_eyeliner_mechanics.html for the real deal.

  20. thompsonjem says:

    Hi

    really too good, I like it

    http://www.lasersec.in

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 93,718 other followers