Voyager 1 Briefly Goes Silent, Scaring Everyone

It’s no big secret at this point that we are looking at the final years of the two venerable Voyager spacecraft. With their power supplies diminishing and their 1970s-era electronics still giving it all they got, their teams are working miracles to stretch out the time to the final goodbye for as long as possible. Despite these efforts Voyager 1 went silent for more than 24 hours on October 18 and 19, with the team still trying to figure out what happened.

The most recent change to Voyager 1 was the same ‘big bang’ switching of multiple instruments to lower-power versions, while keeping an eye on keeping the electronics and fuel at reasonable temperatures. This should give both spacecraft a few more years before power reserves fall below usable levels. Whether this switch is related to this communication blackout is currently unknown.

From the diagnostic data that the team obtained after communications were restored it’s clear that a group of thrusters went offline with backup units kicking in, indicating that the onboard computer detected some kind anomaly with the former. Whether this is a recurrence of the clogged fuel lines that has been observed before will have to be investigated.

We still fervently hope that both Voyagers can make it into the 2030s before both of them will fall silent forever. Final goodbyes are never easy, but we are most grateful to the Voyager teams over the decades for going above and beyond to make sure that literally everything has been attempted before those fateful days arrive.

Thanks to [Mark Stevens] for the tip.

32 thoughts on “Voyager 1 Briefly Goes Silent, Scaring Everyone”

      1. We find V’Ger in about 250 years, we have no way of knowing when it became self-aware. It could have been shortly after it went through what they used to call a blackhole.

        1. If the people wearing red hats can be self-aware
          You are going to have to prove that they are people and that they are self-aware. From where I sit, they are automatons programmed to play the party line over and over without really thinking about what they say. They have the self-awareness of a tape recorder on playback.

          1. Well. Dangit. mangled the formatting.

            If the people wearing red hats can be self-aware

            You are going to have to prove that they are people and that they are self-aware. From where I sit, they are automatons programmed to play the party line over and over without really thinking about what they say. They have the self-awareness of a tape recorder on playback.

          2. That’s what wearing hats will do, not just the red ones.

            a completely new (but off-topic on hackaday) meaning of “wear and tear”

    1. Considering the incredible level of optimization that went into Voyager’s launch window and orbit to squeeze every bit of efficiency possible out of the mission, I’d say it has been hypermiling from the start

  1. Humanities graffiti in a way, our final message “Fred woz ‘ere, once” tagged in paint onto the cosmos.

    More seriously, These two craft are rather special, I believe I will mourn them when they flicker out. My kudos to the brilliant people who are currently running on the smell of an oily rag with all the wheels long gone. The exact same to those in the Mars rover programs, another example of “when it was done right”. And this of course extends to all those before, I recall the launches, since then it has to be countless numbers of people tending the two craft.

    Those engineering feats where a device extends so many times past it’s life, and keeps returning such brilliant science, are humbling. Especially looking at the mess of tangled wires in my breadboard. lol. Designed by engineer giants and looked after with skill.

    Sorry for my sentimental waffle, it’s just… their time is almost passed.

    1. Don’t be sorry;
      The care that went into building anything that “Flies” back in those days shows it’s necessity now. My money is on the electronics getting so cold as they shut off systems that they will suffer “Death by lack of heat”, before the battery can’t supply enough current to power the transmitters and receivers.

      I wonder how long all that electronics has been below -30C….
      Things start to get funky at around -55C or so…

      1. The UV spectrometer heater was turned off in 2012, dropping its temperature below -79 C, and it continued to work. It was some unspecified temperature below -79 C because that’s where the temperature sensor stopped working accurately.

        The spectrometer itself continued to work until April 2016, when it was turned off to save power.

        1. I use to work in aerospace on telemetry transmitters. We would specify some product lines down to -60C. Using Co2 as a coolant occasionally a piece of ice would cause the valve to stay open and your transmitter was down somewhere past -85C, and really doesn’t want to turn on. Junction threshold voltage levels rise.
          They both should be within a few light hours of being one light day away from Earth.
          What an Accomplishment.

    2. Well, there’s something special about technology from the 1970s..
      The way people worked with care and thoughtfullness, the type of wiring,
      the integration size of the components, way of coding/type of computer language etc.
      Except for early CMOS (4000 series) and 70s DRAM, of course. They were very touchy.

      The AMSAT AO-7 satellite -made my civilian amateurs- is about same age (a bit older) and is still functional, as well.
      The reason it fell asleep for a while was an issue with the energy source.

      Sounds familiar, doesn’t it? I wonder how long these probes and satellites would be capable of running if their energy source graciously overspecced.
      If energy shortage was no problem, then the heaters and self-test procedures could go on and on.
      The redundant backup systems could be left active, too.

      Looking at all that 70s tech and appliances that I do have in my own humble home,
      I often wonder if they could be multi generation capable.

      Same goes for the Voyager technology. It’s the first multi generation project of its kind.
      I wonder how it would be if became a blueprint for future generations.

      Maybe the Voyagers could be built again these days?
      Maybe using advancements in technology, but in a way that it stays true to the original?
      Say, by keep using the telemwtry format, the transceivers and the shape?
      The orthicon camera with its filters and the sensors are timeless, too.
      Same goes for the star finder, it worked fine for decades.
      So leaving the RTG, the radio transceiver and the computer.
      Maybe the computers/control system could be implemented as pairs of power-efficient FPGAs?
      As a hardware-emulation, basically?

      The mass saved by doing so could be invested in a lead shielding, to protect the modern electronics from radiation..
      That way there’s a compensation for the “loss” of the heavy old (but robust) electronics that’s nolonger available (rebuilding it 1:1 would be quite a feat)..
      Anyway, let’s keep dreaming.. 🌃

  2. Kudos to the thousands of people who designed and built those spacecraft. Almost unbelievable they are still operating after all these years.

    1. Not such a suprise…. failure of any sort wasn’t considered to be an option for the stuff I built at huge aircraft space ‘n comm

    2. Yeah, absolutely! And it’s even more impressive,
      when we think that the Voyagers were improvised sorta (being derived from Mariner 10).
      I mean, there’s an old saying for this: „there is nothing more permanent than a temporary solution„
      And there’s some wisdom within, I think. Not seldomly, provisory tooth fillings last longer than they should.

      Same goes for prototypes, I think.
      An ugly mess of wires is not seldomly turns out to be longer lasting or more reliable
      than a polished, commercial version of it.

      I’m not saying the Voyagers are messy, but maybe time con-traits caused creative thinking.
      Such as buying alufoil in a supermarket to give space probes their metal dress.
      Stories like that. Or the use of a clever „hack“ to solve an issue, maybe.
      That hack later might turn out as a live saver,
      because it had become useful in an unforeseen situation years later.
      Things like this.. :)

      1. And it just clicked O.o, the craft’s own clock from our frame.

        For nothing more than really considering the relativity train Gedankenexperiment at a larger scale – If the data packet holds an epoch reference the heartbeat nearest won’t be here until 2026-11-19. (/Sheldon voice)

        It’s a Thursday, I hope our physics educators can use the event to inspire the future.

        1. So, taking this to the logical next level: Voyager 1 has been traveling at some fraction of light speed (17 km/s) for these past decades. How much is the accumulated relativistic time shift over that period?

          Going through the arithmetic gives a time dilation of about 1.6 parts per billion, giving an accumulated 2.5 second or so slowing of the clock on Voyager, relative to our “stationary” frame. Not much, and certainly buried in the accuracy of whatever clock is on board.

          But wait! We are sitting part way down the gravity well of Earth and the even deeper one of the sun itself, which Voyager has escaped! Its our clocks that are running slow, by virtue of being still stuck deep in the well.

          Again, going through the arithmetic gets the clocks here on Earth running about 23 seconds slow compared to something up-well for a half century.

          That makes our clocks 20-21 seconds behind Voyager’s.

          Gravity sucks. Relatively speaking, of course.

          1. Hmm looking it up I see figures saying 1.6-2.5 seconds. I wonder if I’m missing something here. In any case, it’s one of the strangest clocks out there.

          2. Barycentric Coordinate Time (TCB) (time frame of an object at rest, far away from the sun) ticks almost 0.5 seconds per year faster than a clock on Earth’s surface. So, cince the 1977 launch, time here on earth has ‘lost’ about 24 seconds behind an object a hundred or more AU out.

            There are (at least) three factors: Earth’s gravity well, the Sun’s (much larger) gravity well, plus Earth’s orbital velocity (30 km/s, even faster than Voyager’s 17 km/s)

  3. It’s probably hardware or software and not the interstellar medium, but I can’t help but wonder sometimes what hope SETI has if we have so much trouble getting signals from our own devices.

  4. I see a lot of declinism here, people longing for a time when more care and effort was placed into each device. I doubt the things humanity is flinging at Mars and other objects in the solar system are exactly cheaply made although maybe they are in comparison?

    Remember… although some useful science still comes from those devices, mostly just due to the fact they are farther away then anything else humanity has ever built… the vast majority of their science was accomplished in the early years when they were still giving us our first views of much of the inner solar system. I am not trying to knock the value of telemetry that helps us validate relativity or find the exact distance to the termination shock. But compare this to the first up close views of Saturn or Jupiter. Which ones inspire the kids to become engineers, astronomers and physicists?

    So my point is.. the “Faster better cheaper” approach was not a mistake. If you can build 4 or 5 probes that explore the inner solar system but don’t make it to the Kuiper Belt vs one probe that lasts so long it gives our children a few new measurements the radiation in interstellar space… Which one gets you more for the money?

    That’s not to say I think we shouldn’t try to send things out that far. Only that we should be making a lot of “faster better cheaper” probes for every one multi-generational Voyager class all-in project.

    And besides, those also are outlasting their main missions. How’s New Horizons doing?

Leave a Reply

Please be kind and respectful to help make the comments section excellent. (Comment Policy)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.