Artificial Muscles To Bring Relief To Robotic Tenseness

Custom, robotic prosthesis are on the rise. In numerous projects, hackers and makers have taken on the challenge. From Enabling The Future, Open Hand Project, OpenBionics to the myriad prosthesis projects on Hackaday.io. Yet, the mechatronics that power most of them are still from the last century. At the end of the day, you can only fit so many miniature motors and gears into a plastic hand, and only so many hydraulics fit onto an arm or leg before it becomes a slow, heavy brick – more hindering than helpful. If only we had a few extra of these light, fast and powerful actuators that help us make it through the day. If only we had artificial muscles.

Artificial muscles are, by generally accepted definition, a device or material that can reversibly change its shape as a response to an external stimulus. This shape change can then be used for actuation, imitating natural muscles. In that sense, a simple hydraulic cylinder does not qualify as an artificial muscle, mainly because neither part of it changes its shape in operation. By contrast, a piece of fishing line that changes its length depending on its temperature can indeed be called an artificial muscle. Decades of research have brought forth promising technologies, so when can we start installing them?

Pneumatic Artificial Muscles (PAM)

PAMs-01

They are known under many names, such as McKibben muscles – after their inventor J. L. McKibben, air muscles, or Pneumatic Artificial Muscles (PAM). In principle, they consist of an inflateable rubber bladder inside a chinese finger trap cylindrical, helically wound braid. When air pressure is applied to the bladder, it inflates inside the constraining braid, which redirects the expansion force into a contractive force through changing it’s braiding angle. However, the more the muscle contracts, the steeper the braiding angle gets, and less force is delivered along the muscle’s length axis. This also stresses the braid material, which must withstand several times the contractive force exercised by the muscle.

 

Animation of a PAM in operation (by Rocketmagnet CC-BY-SA 3.0)
Animation of a PAM in operation (by Rocketmagnet CC-BY-SA 3.0)

Additionally, the pressure inside the bladder must be several times higher than the pressure the muscle can exercise in direction of contraction. Even if an extremely strong braid material was used, and the influence of the braiding angle is neglected, the muscle still contracts against it’s internal air pressure, limiting the contraction ratio and force. The more the muscle contracts, the lesser the force it can exercise. Typical contraction ratios can be between 25% and 35% for the unloaded muscle. Of course, a prosthesis or robot based on PAM actuators requires a strong compressor to pressurize its muscles, along with a multitude of control valves. Invented in the 1950s, they are certainly not the latest breakthrough, but PAMs are still experimentally used in robotics. They are cheap, lightweight and accessible, as well as a great starting point for DIY robotics.

pneupard
This “Pneupard” is actuated entirely by PAMs (Video source).

Electroactive Polymers (EAP)

Polymer-based artificial muscles save themselves from a lot of the drawbacks of pneumatic artificial muscles. Those materials typically experience a shape change in response to a high voltage electrical field, delivered through electrodes that are attached to the material.

Most EAPs are blends of polymers, copolymers, and oils, assembled in complex 3D geometries. The mixing ratio determines the molecular structure and properties of the material. Ferroelectric or piezoelectric materials are used to obtain their electroactive properties. In terms of strain ratio, strength, and efficiency, EAPs are currently one of the more promising artificial muscle technologies.

Yet, after decades of research, the fundamental obstacle for EAPs is still in place: power output. There are piezoelectric polymers, dielectric actuators (DEAs), electrostrictive graft elastomers, liquid crystal elastomers (LCE), ferroelectric polymers, and many more. Their operation principles are throughout based on intramolecular, intermolecular or electrostatic forces. These forces act on very short distances and decrease disproportionally with increasing deformation. Also, EAPs operate in a single cycle, in which the entire mechanical work output of a full contraction must be delivered: Once an EAP is fully contracted or expanded, it can not perform the same molecular interaction again to contract or expand further.

artificial_muscles_power_output
This diagram of specific power output for various artificial muscle types shows that, in theory, some electroactive polymer actuators can deliver a performance similar to natural muscles (left lower corner), however, practical values can still be 10 to 100 times lower. (Source: nasa.gov)
artificial_muscles_carbon_aerogel
Electroactive expansion and contraction of carbon nanotube aerogel bundle (Video source).

One solution to this might lie in carbon nanotubes. Their high electrical conductivity, strength and ability to exist in a wide range of densities, from dense bundles to aerogels may unlock new EAP materials in the future. Twisted bundles of carbon nanotubes have been found to electroactively expand by more than 200%, while also delivering a specific power in the range of 50 W/kg, which puts them in the same league as natural muscles.

However, while a variety of EAPs is already commercially available and finds a wide range of application, from noiseless valve actuators to acoustic transducers, carbon-nanotube-based artificial muscles are still a research subject, and not quite a material you can buy and use.

Thermally actuated artificial muscles

Analogous to EAPs, thermally actuated materials change their shape depending on temperature. The fishing line experiment is a popular example for such a device. It shows that a plain polyethylene string, basically fishing line, is already some sort of muscle: simply by heating it up, it will contract by a few percent. By twisting and coiling up the string, it is possible to create a thermally actuated artificial muscle that can contract by about 50%, and produce up to 4 kN / cm2 of pressure. Unfortunately, a fishing line muscle will contract significantly less under load. Still, their light weight and fast response time – given a fast active heating and cooling system – leads to specific power outputs that may even exceed the performance of natural muscles.

 

artificial_muscles_fishing_line
The fishing line muscle experiment carried out by its original discoverers from the University of Texas at Dallas (Source video).

A stronger alternative to fishing line is Shape Memory Alloy (SMA). SMAs are metallic alloys that can change their shape depending on their temperature. This is possible, because Shape Memory Alloys, unlike other alloys, can co-exist in two phases: Martensite and austenite. In its cool state, an SMA remains in the martensite phase and can be plastically deformed. If the SMA is then heated above its transition temperature, it will change to its austenite phase which “remembers” and restores its original form. Even after it cools down again, it will remain in its original, undeformed shape. This operation mode, where the SMA remembers only its original state, is called one-way shape memory. Two-way shape memory can, among other training methods, be achieved by severely deforming the SMA in its cool state. It will then still return to its original state when heated above the transition temperature, but fall back to the deformed state once it cools down again.

artificial_muscles_SMA
The procedures are very similar: starting from martensite (a), adding a reversible deformation for the one-way effect or severe deformation with an irreversible amount for the two-way (b), heating the sample (c) and cooling it again (d) (caption and images by Wikipedia, image source 1source 2 CC BY-SA 2.5)
stiquito
This little robot “Stiquito” is actuated by tiny nitinol muscles (Video source).

SMAs have a variety of application in many industries, and with their strength and longevity, they are also considered for use as artificial muscles. They are not without drawbacks, however. For example, their operation speed is extremely slow when compared to other materials, which limits their overall power output. Also, with high purity Titanium being the main raw material for high-performing SMAs, such as Nitinol, these materials are still very expensive.

Natural muscles

Natural muscles transform chemical energy directly into mechanical energy in response to an electrical stimulus. Their efficiency may be low, about 25% “from food to foot”, but considering that they double as temporary energy storage and actually transform 50-65% of the chemical energy delivered to them into usable mechanical work, they serve us well.

On a microscopic level, muscles look more like micromechanical assemblies – not too different from machines and technology that is found in applications today. In fact, the “Sliding Filament Model Of Muscle Contraction” shows many similarities with position-type linear motion actuators.

muscles_animation
Myosin filaments with myosin motors (green), Actin filaments (red) (Source video)

During the contraction of a natural muscle, the heads of fibrous protein molecules, which may be called myosin motors, repeatedly perform a stroking movement, which is called the power stroke. The repetitive strokes result in a crawling movement, which allows the myosin fiber to actively pull itself in between the actin filaments. The process is fueled by energy-rich ATP molecules, which are decomposed in the process.

This very tiny linear motor is called a sarcomere, and its main mechanical components are the myosin and actin filaments, along with membranes that hold everything together. Each natural muscle fiber is a bundle of countless of these sarcomeres.

Piezomotor_type_inchworm
Piezo “inchworm” motor animation: Just like the myosin motors crawl along the actin fibers, piezo motors “walk” along a surface. (Animation by LaurensvanLieshout CC BY-SA 3.0)

At the core of any muscle, the mechanical work is delivered from the power strokes of countless myosin molecules, and this stroke is a chemically induced shape change. However, the actual contraction of a muscle is achieved through repetitive stroking – similar to the crawling motion of some piezoelectric motors – and the ability of the involved components to slide in between each other – similar to a hydraulic cylinder assembly. By combining the benefits of molecular shape change and intermolecular bonding forces with complex micromechanics, natual muscles can produce up to 33 N/cm2 of force while contracting by about 30%. Their power output reaches about 100 W per kilogram of muscle mass. Therefore, natural muscles are still unmet as a benchmark, but EAPs, especially carbon nanotube based compounds, are catching up. It may still be a long way until they find their way into robotics. Still, the potential is there, and right now, it’s a great time to start experimenting with accessible technology, such as air muscles.

artificial_muscles_table
EAPs are on the way – be prepared. (Source: nasa.gov)

17 thoughts on “Artificial Muscles To Bring Relief To Robotic Tenseness

  1. I’ve been keeping a mental list of all these technologies over the past few years for a project I have in mind. It was really cool to see someone break them all down in one document. Thanks!

      1. Cool, I was wondering if a system could combine this and the PAM into a whole system, use a pump to transfer a working fluid from the Vacuum muscle to the Pneumatic muscle to move a joint with power in both directions and you have the advantage of a closed system.

    1. Designers of creepy multi-legged robots are going to love those! I wonder if it could be 3D printed easily, I’ve read about some flexible prints but that looks complex.

  2. An Idea I came up with years ago is making PAMs smaller diameter with many rigid rings around them, then bundling several of them together so that the rings on some align with the un-ringed areas on others.

    A natural muscle has many tiny actuators all pulling a short distance. Bundling many small diameter PAMs with the rings making them act as though lots of them are connected end to end should simulate that aspect of natural muscles.

    The concept should work with other technologies that can retract a significant percentage of their relaxed length. Connect many short ones end to end then bundle a lot of those ‘daisy chains’ together.

  3. Thanks that is a very well written article, except it does not mention tendons and their energy storage function, which in natural systems makes up the other half of the functional unit and the ratios are determined by the function of the joint the combined unit is associated with.

    See: http://jap.physiology.org/content/68/3/1033.long

    In machines we would have springs, elastomers or compressible fluids etc.

  4. I have produced some Fishing Line Artificial Muscle before in my garage, the stuff is pretty neat and easy to make. I have woven them into fabric like material with mineral oil rubbed on them and you can get some real strength from them in a bundle like that. Wish I could find a supplier who still makes silver coated nylon in my area, I heard you can use electricity to heat the silver coating and contract the nylon that way.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.