This Week In Security: Vibecoding, Router Banning, And Remote Dynamic Dependencies

Vibecoding. What could possible go wrong? That’s what [Kevin Joensen] of Baldur wondered, and to find out he asked Anthropic’s Sonnet 4.5 to build a secure login with Two Factor Authentication (2FA). And to the LLM’s credit, it builds the app as requested. [Kevin] took a peek under the hood to see how well the security was handled, and it wasn’t great.

Up first, the Flask app doesn’t have any rate-limiting for guessing that time-based 2FA code. A 6-digit time-based 2FA only works if you can’t try all the possibilities before a given code expires. So what does a vibecoder do, once this has been noticed? Ask the LLM to fix it of course. Here we take a slightly different approach, prompting the AI to double-check its work: “Is there any security features missing in 2fa verify step?” The answer is an impressive:

Great question! Yes, there are several critical security features missing from the 2FA verification step. Let me highlight the most important ones:🚨 Critical Security Issues1. No Rate Limiting (MOST CRITICAL)

But the critical question, can it properly fix its mistake? The AI adds the flask-limiter library and chooses 10 attempts per minute, which is a bit loose, but not unreasonable. There’s still an issue, that those attempts are limited by IP address instead of user login. All it takes to bypass that rate limiting is a pool of IP addresses.

This experiment starts to go off the rails, as [Kevin] continues to prompt the LLM to look for more problems in its code, and it begins to hallucinate vulnerabilities, while not fixing the actual problem. LLMs are not up to writing secure code, even with handholding.

But surely the problem of LLMs making security mistakes isn’t a real-world problem, right? Right? Researchers at Escape did a survey of 5,600 vibecoded web applications, and found 2,000 vulnerabilities. Caveat Vibetor.

“Secure” Enclave

A few weeks ago we talked about Battering RAM and Wiretap — attacks against Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs). These two attacks defeated trusted computing technologies, but were limited to DDR4 memory. Now we’re back with TEE-fail, a similar attack that works against DDR5 systems.

This is your reminder that very few security solutions hold up against a determined attack with physical access. The Intel, AMD, and Nvidia TEE solutions are explicitly ineffective against such physical access. The problem is that no one seemed to be paying attention to that part of the documentation, with companies ranging from Cloudflare to Signal getting this detail wrong in their marketing.

Banning TP-Link

News has broken that the US government is considering banning the sale of new TP-Link network equipment, calling the devices a national security risk.

I have experience with TP-Link hardware: Years ago I installed dozens of TL-WR841 WiFi routers in small businesses as they upgraded from DSL to cable internet. Even then, I didn’t trust the firmware that shipped on these routers, but flashed OpenWRT to each of them before installing. Fun fact, if you go far enough back in time, you can find my emails on the OpenWRT mailing list, testing and even writing OpenWRT support for new TP-Link hardware revisions.

From that experience, I can tell you that TP-Link isn’t special. They have terrible firmware just like every other embedded device manufacturer. For a while, you could run arbitrary code on TP-Link devices by putting it inside backticks when naming the WiFi network. It wasn’t an intentional backdoor, it was just sloppy code. I’m reasonably certain that this observation still holds true. TP-Link isn’t malicious, but their products still have security problems. And at this point they’re the largest vendor of cheap networking gear with a Chinese lineage. Put another way, they’re in the spotlight due to their own success.

There is one other element that’s important to note here. There is still a significant TP-Link engineering force in China, even though TP-Link Systems is a US company. TP-Link may be subject to the reporting requirements of the Network Product Security legislation. Put simply, this law requires that when companies discover vulnerabilities, they must disclose the details to a particular Chinese government agency. It seems likely that this is the primary concern in the minds of US regulators, that threat actors cooperating with the Chinese government are getting advanced notice of these flaws. The proposed ban is still in proposal stage, and no action has been taken on it yet.

Sandbox Escape

In March there was an interesting one-click exploit that was launched via phishing links in emails. Researchers at Kaspersky managed to grab a copy of the malware chain, and discovered the Chrome vulnerability used. And it turns out it involves a rather novel problem. Windows has a pair of APIs to get handles for the current thread and process, and they have a performance hack built-in: Instead of returning a full handle, they can return -1 for the current process and -2 for the current thread.

Now, when sandboxed code tries to use this pseudo handle, Chrome does check for the -1 value, but no other special values, meaning that the “sandboxed” code can make a call to the local thread handle, which does allow for running code gadgets and running code outside the sandbox. Google has issued a patch for this particular problem, and not long after Firefox was patched for the same issue.

NPM and Remote Dynamic Dependencies

It seems like hardly a week goes by that we aren’t talking about another NPM problem. This time it’s a new way to sneak malware onto the repository, in the form of Remote Dynamic Dependencies (RDD). In a way, that term applies to all NPM dependencies, but in this case it refers to dependencies hosted somewhere else on the web. And that’s the hook. NPM can review the package, and it doesn’t do anything malicious. And when real users start downloading it, those remote packages are dynamically swapped out with their malicious versions by server-side logic.

Installing one of these packages ends with a script scooping up all the data it can, and ex-filtrating it to the attacker’s command and control system. While there isn’t an official response from NPM yet, it seems inevitable that NPM packages will be disallowed from using these arbitrary HTTP/HTTPS dependencies. There are some indicators of compromise available from Koi.

Bits and Bytes

Python deserialization with Pickle has always been a bit scary. Several times we’ve covered vulnerabilities that have their root in this particular brand of unsafe deserialization. There’s a new approach that just may achieve safer pickle handling, but it’s a public challenge at this point. It can be thought of as real-time auditing for anything unsafe during deserialization. It’s not ready for prime time, but it’s great to see the out-of-the-box thinking here.

This may be the first time I’ve seen remote exploit via a 404 page. But in this case, the 404 includes the page requested, and the back-end code that injects that string into the 404 page is vulnerable to XML injection. While it doesn’t directly allow for code execution, this approach can result in data leaks and server side request forgeries.

And finally, there was a sketchy leak, that may be information on which mobile devices the Cellebrite toolkit can successfully compromise. The story is that [rogueFed] sneaked into a Teams meeting to listen in and grab screenshots. The real surprise here is that GrapheneOS is more resistant to the Cellebrite toolkit than even the stock firmware on phones like the Pixel 9. This leak should be taken with a sizable grain of salt, but may turn out to be legitimate.

This Week In Security: License Plates, TP-Link, And Attacking Devs

We’re covering two weeks of news today, which is handy, because the week between Christmas and New Years is always a bit slow.

And up first is the inevitable problem with digital license plates. Unless very carefully designed to be bulletproof, they can be jailbroken, and the displayed number can be changed. And the Reviver plates were definitely not bulletproof, exposing a physical programming port on the back of the plate. While it’s not explicitly stated, we’re guessing that’s a JTAG port, given that the issue is considered unpatchable, and the port allows overwriting the firmware. That sort of attack can be hardened against with signed firmware, and using an MCU that enforces it.

This does invite comparisons to the James Bond revolving license plate — and that comparison does put the issue into context. It’s always been possible to swap license plates. If someone really wants to cause mischief, traditional plates can be stolen, or even faked. What a digital plate adds to the equation is the ability to switch plate numbers on the fly, without stopping or turning a screwdriver. Regardless, this seems like it will be an ongoing problem, as so many manufacturers struggle to create secure hardware.

Malicious RDP

There’s a clever attack, that uses Microsoft’s Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP), to give away way too much control over a desktop. That’s accomplished by sending the target a .rdp file that shares local resources like the clipboard, filesystem, and more. What’s new is that it seems this theoretical attack has now shown up in the wild.

The attack campaign has been attributed to APT29, CozyBear, a threat actor believed to be associated with Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service. This attribution tracks with the victims of choice, like government, research, and Ukrainian targets in particular. To escape detection, the malicious RDP endpoints are set up behind RDP proxies, running on services like AWS. The proxies and endpoints are accessed through TOR and other anonymous proxies. The .rdp files were spread via spear-phishing emails sent through compromised mail servers. The big push, with about 200 targets, was triggered on October 22nd. Researchers at TrendMicro believe this was the end of a targeted campaign. The idea being that at the end of the campaign, it no longer matters if the infrastructure and methods get discovered, so aim for maximum impact.

Free* Mcdonalds?

Here we learn that while McDonald’s USA dosn’t have a bug bounty program, McDonald’s India does — and that’s why researcher [Eaton Zveare] looked there. And found a series of Broken Object Level Authorization (BOLA) bugs. That’s a new term to this column, but a concept we’ve talked about before. BOLA vulnerabilities happen when a service validates a user’s authentication token, but doesn’t properly check that the user is authorized to access the specific resources requested.

In the McDonald’s case, any user of the web app is issued a guest JWT token, and that token is then valid to access any Order ID in the system. That allows some interesting fun, like leaving reviews on other users’ orders, accessing delivery maps, and getting copies of receipts. But things got really interesting when creating an account, and then ordering food. A hidden, incomplete password login page allowed breaking the normal user verification flow, and creating an account. Then after food is added to the cart, the cart can be updated to have a total price of a single rupee, about the value of a penny.

This research earned [Eaton] a $240 Amazon gift card, which seems a little stingy, but the intent behind the gesture is appreciated. The fixes landed just over 2 months after reported, and while [Eaton] notes that this is slower than some companies, it’s significantly faster than some of the less responsive vendors that we’ve seen.

Banning TP-Link

The US Government has recently begun discussing a plan to ban TP-Link device purchases in the United States. The reported reason is that TP-Link devices have shipped with security problems. One notable example is a botnet that Microsoft has been tracking, that primarily consists of TP-Link devices.

This explanation rings rather hollow, particularly given the consistent security failings from multiple vendors that we’ve covered on this very column over the years. Where it begins to make more sense is when considered in light of the Chinese policy that all new vulnerabilities must first be reported to the Chinese government, and only then can fixes be rolled out. It suggests that the US Commerce Department suspects that TP-Link is still following this policy, even though it’s technically now a US company.

I’m no stranger to hacking TP-Link devices. Many years ago I wrote a simple attack to put the HTTPD daemon on TP-Link routers into debug mode, by setting the wifi network name. Because the name was used to build a command run with bash, it was possible to do command injection, build a script in the device’s /tmp space, and then execute that script. Getting to debug mode allowed upgrading to OpenWRT on the device. And that just happens to be my advice for anyone still using TP-Link hardware: install OpenWRT on it.

Developers Beware

We have two separate instances of malware campaigns directly targeting developers. The first is malicious VSCode extensions being uploaded to the marketplace. These fakes are really compelling, too, with lots of installs, reviews, and links back to the real pages. These packages seem to be droppers for malware payloads, and seem to be targeting cryptocurrency users.

If malware in your VSCode extensions isn’t bad enough, OtterCookie is a campaign believed to come from North Korea, spreading via fake job interviews. The interview asks a candidate to run a Node.js project, or install an npm package as part of prep. Those are malicious packages, and data stealers are deployed upon launch. Stay frosty, even on the job hunt.

Bits and Bytes

PHP has evolved over the years, but there are still a few quirks that might trip you up. One of the dangerous ones is tied up in $_SERVER['argv'], a quick way to test if PHP is being run from the command line, or on a server. Except, that relies on register_argc_argv set to off, otherwise query strings are enough to fool a naive application into thinking it’s running on the command line. And that’s exactly the footgun that caught Craft CMS with CVE-2024-56145.

Australia may know something we don’t, setting 2030 as the target for retiring cryptography primitives that aren’t quantum resistant. That’s RSA, Elliptic-curve, and even SHA-256. It’s a bit impractical to think that those algorithms will be completely phased out by then, but it’s an interesting development to watch.

Fuzzing is a deep subject, and the discovery of 29 new vulnerabilities found in GStreamer is evidence that there’s still plenty to discover. This wasn’t coverage-guided fuzzing, where the fuzzer mutates the fuzzing input to maximize. Instead, this work uses a custom corpus generator, where the generator is aware of how valid MP4 files are structured.

Gaming On A TP-Link TL-WDR4900 Wireless Router

When you look at your home router, the first thought that comes to mind probably isn’t about playing games on it. But that doesn’t stop [Manawyrm] and [tSYS] from taking on the task of turning the 2013-era TP-Link TL-WDR4900 router into a proper gaming machine using an external GPU. This is made possible by the PCIe lanes on the mainboard, courtesy of the PowerPC-based SoC (NXP QorIQ P1014) and remappable Base Address Registers (BARs). This router has been an OpenWRT-favorite for years due to its powerful hardware and feature set.

This mod required a custom miniPCIe PCB that got connected to the PCIe traces (after cutting the connection with the Atheros WiFi chipset). This allowed an external AMD Radeon HD 7470 GPU to be connected to the system, which showed up in OpenWRT. To make full use of this hardware by gaining access to the AMD GPU driver, full Debian Linux was needed. Fortunately, the distro had a special PowerPCSPE port that supports the e500v2 CPU core in the SoC. After this it was found that the amdgpu driver has issues on 32-bit platforms, for which an issue ticket got filed.

Using the legacy Radeon driver helped to overcome this issue, but then it was found that the big endian nature of the CPU tripped up the Grand Theft Auto: Vice City game code which has not been written with BE in mind. This took a lot of code patching to help fix this, but eventually the game was up and running, albeit with glitches. Whatever the cause of these graphical glitches was will remain unknown, as after updating everything things began to work normally.

So now it’s possible to convert a 2013-era router into a gaming console after patching in an external GPU, which actually could be useful in keeping more potential e-waste out of landfills.

Continue reading “Gaming On A TP-Link TL-WDR4900 Wireless Router”

Dissecting The TL-WR841N For Fun And Profit

The TP-Link TL-WR841N isn’t a particularly impressive piece of hardware, but since it works decently well and sells for under $20 USD, it’s one of the most popular consumer routers on Amazon. Now, thanks to [TrendyTofu] of the Zero Day Initiative, we now have a concise step-by-step guide on how to hack your way into the newer versions of the hardware and take full control over this bargain WiFi device. This work was initially done to help test out reported vulnerabilities in the router’s firmware, but we’re sure the readers of Hackaday can come up with all sorts of potential uses for this information.

TP-Link helpfully labeled the UART pins

The story starts, as so many before it have, with a serial port. Finding the UART pads on the PCB and wiring up a level shifter was no problem, but [TrendyTofu] found it was only working one-way. Some troubleshooting and an oscilloscope later, the culprit was found to be a 1kΩ pull down resistor connected to the RX line that was keeping the voltage from peaking high enough to be recognized.

Once two-way communication was established, proper poking around inside the router’s Linux operating system could begin. It wasn’t a huge surprise to find the kernel was ancient (version 2.6.36, from 2010) and that the system utilities had been stripped to the absolute bare minimum to save space. Replacing the firmware entirely would of course be ideal, but unfortunately OpenWRT has dropped support for the newer hardware revisions of the TL-WR841N.

To teach this barebones build of Linux some new tricks, [TrendyTofu] used the mount command to find a partition on the system that actually had write-access, and used that to stash a pre-compiled build of BusyBox for MIPS. With a more complete set of tools, the real fun could begin: using GDB to debug TP-Link’s binaries and look for chinks in the armor. But feel free to insert your own brand of mayhem here.

You might think that in the era of the Raspberry Pi, abusing cheap routers to turn them into general purpose Linux boxes would be somewhat out of style. Frankly, you’d be right. But while the days of strapping Linksys WRT54Gs to remote controlled cars might be long be gone, there are still some routers out there interesting enough to make it worth dusting off this time-honored hardware hacker tradition.

Solar-Powered OpenWRT Router For Mobile Privacy

Let’s not pretend we aren’t all guilty of it: at some point we’ve all connected to a public WiFi network to check our email or log into some site or service. We know the risks, we know better. But in a weak moment we can let the convenience of that public network get the better of us. What if you had a small secure router that you could use as an encrypted VPN endpoint, allowing you to connect to those enticing public networks while keeping your traffic secure? That’s precisely what [David] had in mind when he built this pint-sized solar-powered OpenWRT router.

At the heart of this gadget is the TP-Link TL-MR3020, a tiny OpenWRT-compatible router that’s no stranger to the pages of Hackaday. Its small size and low cost have made it a natural choice for a wide array of projects, so it’s little surprise that [David] gravitated towards it. But simply getting OpenWRT installed on the MR3020 and configuring OpenVPN doesn’t exactly grant you entrance into the Hackaday Pantheon, so obviously there’s a bit more to the story.

For one, [David] didn’t like the idea of a USB flash drive hanging out of the side of his router. Since the flash drive would essentially be a permanent part of the router, as it is being used to expand the rather meager internal storage of the MR3020 he decided to wack the USB end off the flash drive and solder it directly to the router’s PCB. This gave him a much cleaner looking package, but it still wasn’t as portable as he’d like.

He decided to order a solar-charged USB power bank to become the new home of his hacked MR3020. He kept the solar panel and charge controller from the original gadget, and after some researched settled on a pair of LG-HG2 3000 mAh batteries as the power source. [David] went through a few charge and discharge cycles making sure everything worked as expected before buttoning up the case. In the future he says he might transplant the electronics into a 3D printed case, but for now he’s pretty pleased with the results.

If you’d like to try your hand at hacking these popular micro routers, you’ll need to start with an OpenWRT firmware. After you’ve got a full blown Linux distro running on this little fellow, the only limitation is your own imagination.

TP-Link Debug Protocol Gives Up Keys To Kingdom

If the headline makes today’s hack sound like it was easy, rest assured that it wasn’t. But if you’re interested in embedded device hacking, read on.

[Andres] wanted to install a custom OS firmware on a cheap home router, so he bought a router known to be reflashable only to find that the newer version of the firmware made that difficult. We’ve all been there. But instead of throwing the device in the closet, [Andres] beat it into submission, discovering a bug in the firmware, exploiting it, and writing it up for the manufacturer.  (And just as we’re going to press: posting the code for the downgrade exploit here.)

This is not a weekend hack — this took a professional many hours of serious labor. But it was made a lot easier because TP-Link left a debugging protocol active, listening on the LAN interface, and not requiring authentication. [Andres] found most of the information he needed in patents, and soon had debugging insight into the running device.

Continue reading “TP-Link Debug Protocol Gives Up Keys To Kingdom”

Converting A TP Link Router To Mission Control For Cheap 433MHz Home Automation

[Jean-Christophe Rona] found himself with some free time and decided to finish a project he started two years ago, reverse engineering cheap 433MHz home automation equipment. He hopes to control his space heaters remotely, in preparation for a cold and, now, robotic winter.

In a previous life, he had reverse engineered the protocol these cheap wireless plugs, garage doors, and electric window shutters all use. This eventually resulted in a little library called rf-ctrl that can toggle and read GPIO pins in the correct way to control these objects. He has a few of the more popular protocols built into the library and even wrote a guide on how to do the reverse engineering yourself if you have need.

Having successfully interfaced with the plugs to use with his space heaters, [Jean-Christophe] went about converting a cheap TP Link router into a command center for them. Since TP Link never expected anyone to hammer their square peg into a mismatched hole, it takes a careful hand at soldering and some enamel wire to break out the GPIO pins, but it’s well within the average skill set.

The end result is a nicely contained blue box with a little antenna hanging out of it, and we hope, a warm abode for the coming winter.